PDA

View Full Version : Blender vs The Others (Maya and 3DMax)



tioilmo
09-Oct-05, 19:54
In your opinion if you could compare Blender 3D with the best CG Softwares like Maya & 3DMax , what would be your grade to Blender 3D?

Suppose Maya and Max have 10 points, what is your grade to Blender?

10 - The same level :D
9 - Almost there :)
8 - I believe in this guy 8)
7 - Its enough to me ;)
6 - Would be better :|
5 - It is in the middle of the way [>]
4 - It can not be comparable [!]
3 - Lets talk about soccer :(
2 - Blender ? Whats is Blender ? :-|
1 - You must be kidding, its so far from them :<

Fweeb
09-Oct-05, 19:55
/me quietly shakes head and points to the search tool.

bmax
09-Oct-05, 19:57
/me quietly shakes head and points to the search tool.

No kidding!

...to think I was convinced these threads were finally a thing of the past...

cara-rj
09-Oct-05, 21:34
As the answers above were quite obvious, there is no such thing as best software.


tioilmo, como você é brasileiro, vai em português mesmo:
Faça uma pesquisa sobre que ferramentas o Blender oferece, veja trabalhos finalizados nele, se inspire a conhecer o programa.

Não se deixe levar por propaganda, só serve para causar mal-estar nos fóruns.

Rocketman
09-Oct-05, 21:42
Funny, I can sort of understand what cara_rj is saying...

cara-rj
09-Oct-05, 21:57
Rocketman,
all I said was:
"Do a research about Blender's tools, see some finished works, get inspired to know the software.

Don't believe only in marketing..."

That's all. 8)

tioilmo
09-Oct-05, 22:03
People used to say Blender 3d is very far from the others, I am just starting in Animation 3D and until now I could not identify a great difference between the free one and the expensive others. I used a free limited version of Maya in my first try in 3D. Now I am using Blender 3D Opensource and I think it is good enough for amateurs like me. I am not sure about heavy users. Thats why my research exists!

I think if I have an idea about this point I will be able to decide continuing with Blender or it is the time to change to not be frustrated in the future.

Thanks

Tio Ilmo

Alltaken
09-Oct-05, 22:36
the weather is pretty crap right now isn't it.

Alltaken

phlip
09-Oct-05, 23:03
Copied and pasted from yet another of these threads:

Go go gadget forum search (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/search.php)!
Blender is as good as the expensive "professional" (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=43463)
Blender & Maya (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=29211)
I can no longer work in Maya thanks to Blender! (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=43266) (though that one's a bit one-sided)
Girlfriend vs Blender (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=41943) (included with the other XYZ vs Blener threads for completeness)
Blender or Maya? (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=34254)
Blender vs 3Ds Max (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=28399)
Blender will surpass all commercial 3D apps in the future... (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=34103)
For: "Which 3D software should I get?" (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=33377) - a very good read
Blender Vs. 3DS MAX (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=48755)
why blender, why maya (http://www.elysiun.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=50882)

A bit of light reading for you ;)

I'm sure there's more too, I just tried one search and picked the more obvious threads on the first few pages... more detailed searches and clicking more threads will of course lead to more information.

To save time I suggest that people read these threads and pick up where they left off, rather than starting the argument from scratch. It will save a lot of time in the long run. By which I mean: skip the rehashing of points that happens every time, skip the religious flamewar and go straight to whatever it is that follows that that we've never discovered 'cause we get stuck at the flamewar stage.

nebx
09-Oct-05, 23:06
tioilmo,

First of all welcome to Elysiun and Blender. This is a question that is asked maybe once a week here, so there are LOTS of posts regarding it already. Do a search and read up on the features etc...

I'm having a tough time understanding your rating scale but id say (and this is just my opinion) that its somewhere at a 7, give or take. All of us here like it and that's enough for us. If you ask someone who uses an expensive 3D package you'll likely get a much more negative answer.

There are many people around the world who use Blender on some professional level. You prolly won't hear much about it, but it does happen. Bear in mind though that most of the professional 3D packages have a lot of slick marketing voodoo behind them and many people are easily swayed by this.

If you are serious about getting into 3D then you should learn as many 3D applications as you can legally aquire. Blender will provide you with a great start and the future of it looks pretty bright honestly. But do yourself a favor and learn as much as you can about all of the different apps including Blender so you can answer this question based upon your own experience, because you'll never really be happy with the opinions of others.

Lastly, it dosen't really matter what software you choose because it's only software it can do nothing without and experienced artist behind it. Learn the concepts of art Color Theory, Design Fundamentals, etc... and you'll find that Blender can do nearly everything you want it to do. Look around on this forum there is some amazing work that has come out of this community. And, check out the video tutorials too http://www.blender3d.org/cms/Video_Tutorials.396.0.html .

:)

tioilmo
10-Oct-05, 07:36
I think this guy (Nebx) had the answer I was looking for.

Thanks man...


Tio Imo

Riskbreaker
10-Oct-05, 07:39
I dont know if its been mentioned but shouldnt these threads be localised into one thread and made sticky with an eye catching subject title like "Comparing Blender to Big Boy Toys" or "Blender Vs bla bla bla".

Just a thought. Might not even be a good one, but still.

bmax
10-Oct-05, 08:03
"Comparing Blender to Big Boy Toys" or "Blender Vs bla bla bla".

Don't think that'd be a good idea. Threads like that have a reputation for insciting massive and rabid flamewars. :-?